AITA for Wanting an Open Marriage?

Photo of author

By Luciana

Yes, you are.

Because let’s be real, if you are asking for an open marriage, what you are really saying is, “I am not happy here anymore.” It is not about freedom, or excitement, or being progressive.

It is about searching for something outside because what you have inside the relationship no longer feels enough. That is not a solution, it is a symptom, and pretending otherwise only delays the inevitable.

Open marriages spark endless debate. Some call them modern and progressive, others see them as the beginning of the end.

To me, the answer is clear: if you are even considering an open marriage, it usually means you are no longer happy or fulfilled in your relationship.

The Real Reason People Bring It Up

Wanting to open a marriage is rarely about curiosity. More often, it is about:

  • Feeling unfulfilled and looking for something you are not getting at home
  • Avoiding the pain of facing a relationship that is already breaking
  • Staying for safety, finances, or fear, while trying to find an easy way out

In other words, it is not a fix, it is a sign.

Why It Often Leads to Divorce

Suggesting an open marriage can feel like a shortcut to happiness, but it often cracks open truths that have been ignored for too long. Instead of bringing couples closer, it usually pushes them further apart.

In many cases, it ends with divorce, not because of the open marriage itself, but because the foundation was already weak.

My Honest Opinion on Open Marriages

Here is the blunt truth: if you are fulfilled and connected, the thought of opening your marriage will not even cross your mind. Exploring other options usually points to deeper problems that are not being addressed.

For some couples, an open marriage may work with genuine interest and clear boundaries. But for most, it is less about excitement and more about escape.

Sometimes we stay in relationships for reasons like safety, children, or finances. But trying to save a broken marriage by opening it is like putting tape over a crack in the glass. It will not hold.

My take is simple: an open marriage is rarely about love or progress, it is usually a signal that the relationship is already closing.

What do you think, is an open marriage a solution, or just a sign of trouble? Share your thoughts in the comments, your opinion might be exactly what someone else needs to hear.