November 30, 2014
The Unalterable Other

Michael Eric Dyson’s piece in today’s New York Times is the most perceptive and persuasive thing I’ve seen yet on the Ferguson murder. Excerpt:

Bill Cosby didn’t invent the politics of respectability — the belief that good behavior and stern chiding will cure black ills and uplift black people and convince white people that we’re human and worthy of respect. But he certainly gave it a vernacular swagger that has since been polished by Barack Obama. The president has lectured black folk about our moral shortcomings before cheering audiences at college commencements and civil rights conventions. And yet his themes are shopworn and mix the innocuous and the insidious: pull your pants up, stop making racial excuses for failure, stop complaining about racism, turn off the television and the video games and study, don’t feed your kids fried chicken for breakfast, be a good father.

As big a fan as he is of respectability politics, Mr. Obama is the most eloquent reminder that they don’t work, that no matter how smart, sophisticated or upstanding one is, and no matter how much chastising black people pleases white ears, the suspicions about black identity persist. Despite his accomplishments and charisma, he is for millions the unalterable “other” of national life, the opposite of what they mean when they think of America.

Barack Obama, like Michael Brown, is changed before our eyes into a monstrous thing that lacks humanity: a monkey, a cipher, a black hole that kills light. One might expect the ultimate target of this black otherness to have sympathy for its lesser targets, who also have lesser standing and lesser protection, like the people in Ferguson, in Ohio, in New York, in Florida, and all around the country, who can’t keep their unarmed children from being cut down in the street by callous cops who leave their bodies to stiffen into rigor mortis in the presence of horrified onlookers…

He has employed a twin strategy: the “heroic explicit,” in which he deliberately and clearly assails black moral failure and poor cultural habits, and the “noble implicit,” in which he avoids linking whites to social distress or pathology and speaks in the broadest terms possible, in grammar both tentative and tortured, about the problems we all confront. It’s an effort that hinges on false equivalencies between black and white and the mistaken identification of effect for cause.


Posted by Jerome Doolittle at November 30, 2014 05:21 PM
Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):


Obama isn't the only one. Hillary Clinton hasn't said word one about Ferguson, and never will. Nor, so far as I know, have any of the other Democratic hopefuls. The rot in our society goes very deep, and they know it.

Posted by: Red Tide on November 30, 2014 5:39 PM

Read the piece.

The black community is struggling with the concept that Obama is not actually the first black president; he's best viewed as the first president who is only half white.

And his upbringing was 100 % white.

And the non-white half was foreign, not African-American.

He is married to a black woman and his kids no doubt self-identify as black.

But he doesn't, and that is why he was able to reach the presidency.

Posted by: on November 30, 2014 8:58 PM

I would like to know what the actual fuck would be wrong with eating a piece of fried chicken for breakfast? Seriously, it would at least have some protein. Better than the barely disguised candy that is 99.9% of "breakfast cereals."

Sorry to focus in on that, but I only recently became aware of the infamous "Popeye's chicken speech," and it happened in 2008! A good thing I hadn't I suppose, because I was so disgusted, I mightn't have voted for him if I had heard it back then.

Posted by: on December 1, 2014 10:12 AM
Post a comment

Email Address:



Remember info?