The Texas State Board of Education seems to be worried that children aren’t bored enough by history, so they’ve decided to make it even more tedious. According to a proposed new set of guidelines for history textbooks, “Texas high school students would learn about such significant individuals and milestones of conservative politics as Newt Gingrich and the rise of the Moral Majority — but nothing about liberals.”
The first draft for proposed standards in United States History Studies Since Reconstruction says students should be expected “to identify significant conservative advocacy organizations and individuals, such as Newt Gingrich, Phyllis Schlafly and the Moral Majority.”
Phyllis Schlafly? Good God. What have the children of Texas done to deserve this kind of torture? Isn’t the Texas State Board of Education familiar with the clause in the Constitution forbidding cruel and unusual punishment?
This kind of thing has become so blandly typical of today’s conservatives it hardly merits any comment at all (and, according to the article in the Houston Chronicle, the guidelines probably won’t even pass). It’s just another example of how the far right is running scared and has to resort to force in order to keep their ideas in circulation, whether by showing up to town hall meetings packing heat or coercing children to memorize the names of their ten-cent heroes. It’s the desperate, sputtering gasp of a dying movement.
The fact that conservatives want Newt Gingrich and Phyllis Schlafly in history books is a tacit admission that they are, in fact, history baby! Engraving them in high school textbooks is the shortest and surest way to ensure that they’ll be forgotten and ignored by an entire generation of young Americans. Once the school system turns them into plastic icons like the Founding Fathers, the very mention of their names will induce fidgeting and/or drowsiness. With any luck, it might even foster a bit of rebellion. This thought comforts me.
plastic icons like the Founding Fathers
Nicely put. I'm a history buff - but that's in spite of the way I was taught about our history, not because of it. One of the things that strikes me about our Founders is how truly subversive they remain to this day. I guess that's why we so cleverly camouflage them with holidays and mattress sales.
Making American history boring is a monumental achievement. Not an admirable one, of course. But monumental nonetheless.
Posted by: Roddy McCorley on August 23, 2009 1:20 PMWell, if I ever have to compete with anyone based on knowledge, please let it be against a texan.
Posted by: evil is evil on August 23, 2009 1:29 PMY'know, it occurs to me that if you're gonna take "the liberals" out of American history, you're going to have to teach that we're still part of Great Britain...
Posted by: Roddy McCorley on August 23, 2009 4:49 PMThe American Aurora will always be around as an alternative to the "history" books. Regarding the founding fathers, I am reading "The , the "American Aurora" and the reporting of Benny Bache (pronounced Beach), the grandson of Benjamin Franklin. Well worth the time for a lesson in what the founding fathers really thought. The kids in Texas who want to really know what the history books said will eventually find out if they look long enough.
http://www.nytimes.com/books/first/r/rosenfel-aurora.html
Posted by: Buck on August 23, 2009 6:12 PMI'm hoping kids, and adults, read books like Lies My Teacher Told Me, which details hundreds of falsehoods that inhabit nearly all our history textbooks, and points to the issue the falsehoods have in common: they promote the great-man theory of history. American high-school history texts portray the founding of the country as a one-time event managed by people of nearly superhuman ability; we'll never see their like again, and we need to kowtow to their memories. And, by extension, to their successors.
If kids look, which they won't because they'll be watching TV or movies or video games, they'll eventually find folks like Richard Hofstadter and I.F. Stone. The real info's available, but it's covered with a thick slime of bullshit.
Posted by: Chuck Dupree on August 23, 2009 6:35 PM